Saturday, 11 July 2009

VLEs: problems with the one-stop shop

VLEs. I'm not a fan.

It's taken me a long time to articulate why I dislike them so much, and I'm not finished yet, but here are some initial points:

VLES don't do one thing well. They do two things badly.

Specifically, they do administration and they do teaching/learning. Not the same!

Administrative activities (e.g. creating class lists, tracking attendance, allocating parking spaces) (yes, I've seen a VLE that does that) and learning activities (e.g. collaborating on a projects, research, work submission) have different stakeholders and different management requirements, which, in turn, require different infrastructures.

Administration:

Administration can only be done by designated, authorised people within a known & standard framework - such as the teacher (who is authorised) taking the roll (which is standard). There is a significant disadvantage to the teacher innovating by taking the roll in a different way, or by involving the students in the roll call, or taking the roll differently from all the other teachers. Every teacher - and only teachers - must take the roll the same way for the overall system to work.

Administration is never collaborative. Administrators intrinsically have set roles in a hierarchy. Individual innovation does not help administration.

Teaching and learning:

Good teaching and learning (in my opinion) is all about freeing up the individual. (Isn't that the goal of education? To free the learner? Education creates knowledge in the mind that wasn't there before - it is intrinsically innovative.)

Innovation - by the teacher, by the learner, by the group - is the key deal, and it is supported beautifully by collaborative technologies. We've never had it better for constructivist pedagogy. The sharing, swapping, and creation of new knowledge - all of this can be done, and is done, in social network environments, both online and in the physical world.

But not in VLEs.

One round peg, one square peg, one round hole

Both administration and pedagogy are necessary in schools. They are also completely different in what infrastructure they require. This (in my opinion) has been the great failing of VLEs - they all try to squeeze the round pedagogy peg into the square administration hole.

It hasn't worked very well. Trying to coax collaboration in what is effectively an administrative environment, without the porous walls that social media thrives on, hasn't worked. The 'walled garden' of the VLE is just not as fertile as the juicy jungle outside, and not enough seeds blow in on the wind.

That's why I'm always cautious of the 'one-stop-shop' approach in education - administration and pedagogy are very, very different shops. It's like having a fishmongers and a haberdashers sharing the same store - no discernible upsides, but a LOT of downsides (stinky fabric springs to mind).

The limits of the one-stop-shop: real world examples

On that note, a lot of good lessons for e-business can be found in 'real-world' business. For example: In the real world, there is a sliding scale between quality of product and specificity of store. Clothes provides a good example:

Tesco: sells everything from food to electronics, and all clothes from underwear to fancy dresses. Has very low quality clothes.

H & M: sells men's and women's clothes for many occasions together, has medium quality clothes.

Savile Row tailor: sells only men's clothes, and of that, only suits, has extremely high quality clothes.

The higher the specificity, the higher the quality.

...the point that is interesting here is not that Tesco sells bad clothes, but that there is no example of a Tesco-like sells-lots-of-different-things store that sells very high-quality clothes. (Harrods may be the exception here, but theirs is a very old business model that I don't believe anyone is now trying to reproduce.)

An andecdote

Way Back When I was still in schools, I started a project with some Australian year 8 students. I got them all to write blogs. The goal was to teach them some persuasive writing skills, how to 'play nicely' online, and just a little dash of html.

Two weeks in, an extra blog popped up - one of the kids in the next class had joined in because he thought it looked fun.

I won't be impressed by any VLE until it can let it's own members do the same.

Person names as unique ids (again)

Yesterday, I finally changed my twitter name.

I really liked my old one. I liked being 'coelacanthro'. I thought it was super clever - 'coelacanth' being a super impressive dinosaur fish, which tied in nicely with 'anthro' for person. Additionally, it was extremely unlikely that anyone else would use it in another environment. But:

- It's hard to spell (which makes it hard to remember)
- It's hard to pronounce (which makes it hard to mention in non-text environments)
- It's got a lot of letters in it (which makes it inconvenient to retweet)

Which cumulatively means: it's no good.

So I had to choose a replacement. There are two options here: Your actual name, and Not. My actual name is Zoe Rose. For my professional reputation, I would love to be Zoe Rose, or zoerose at least. But Zoe Rose is problematic:

- There's a surprisingly large number of people called Zoe Rose
- There's a surprisingly large number of people who claim to be called Zoe Rose
- There's a pornographic actress who claims to be called Zoe Rose

'Zoe Rose' is non-unique. It's taken in just about every social media environment, and it's not immediately evident which Zoe Rose I am. And I would just HATE to ever be confused with the pornographic one, by anyone. It seems that to maintain my professional reputation, I have to make the decidedly unprofessional leap to using not-my-name.

So, I've chosen 'memexer', in conformance with this blog and in homage to Vannevar Bush (See sidebar). The next question is - will I be able to use it in all my social media environments? Should I? Will it have enough longevity?

Will it still look even vaguely professional in five years time? If not, will we have found a better solution by then?

(It may well be moot, anyhow - when I changed my name, twitter locked me out of my account. Time will tell if I ever get it back...)



Thursday, 9 July 2009

Dude, what?

So. A strange thing happened to me on the twitter today.

I got a dm from a friend, a man who I've met & gone drinking with in real life. A nice man. A man who has given me every impression of being someone who knows how to spell. A man who may not be responsible for the below, and therefore, will not be named here. (Yet.)

Here's a non-verbatim (I'll get to that) transcript of the conversation, over the course of twenty minutes or so:

him: u r hot :p
me: dude, what?
him: dude?! duuuuuuude!?!?
me: Don't mean to sound stroppy, and I may be missing the joke, but you realise you're talking to a married lady, right?

No response.

THEN something weird happened.

I went to check my dms, and 'u r hot :p' wasn't there. Creepy. So I dm'ed him:

me: how did you retract that dm?
him: ?!?!?!?
me: I had a dm from you that said 'u r hot :p', and now it's gone

...and then it got weirder again. All his dms disappeared. That was disconcerting, but worse, MINE to HIM disappeared as well!

By this point I was assuming that someone had hacked my/his account, or both, and that I probably had a new tweet-eating, emoticon-based virus. (That's why it's not verbatim - the entire record of conversation has been wiped). But no! No, it's weirder than that. My colleague and I experimented, and here is what we found out:

If you dm someone, and then delete it, it disappears from both your streams

If someone dms you, and you delete it, it disappears from both your streams

Madness!

Call me crazy, but I don't like the idea of having my work wiped at someone else's whim. That's peanuts, though, compared to the scary prospect of the bullying that this could enable. You could send as vicious a message as you could fit in 140, and remove it before trouble happened.

So all - if you (or more importantly, your kids) ever get an unwelcome dm that you want to have on the record, screenshot it.

And as for you, Mr :p, I'm going to go on ahead and give you the benefit of the doubt. I'm assuming that you left your account open and someone with an aversion to vowels and a fondness for punctuation used it to play silly buggers. I could be wrong. You could be a jerk.

But I really, really hope not.


**UPDATE** No, it wasn't him - it was a prankster. Thank goodness for that.

Friday, 12 June 2009

A true story

...So, I was sitting at the pub reading a book, when I couldn't help overhearing the conversation at the table next to mine.

(in other words: I was eavesdropping.)

Three people, in their twenties, were busily discussing a Project - one was talking about flash, another, nerve endings and neural paths.

I couldn't help myself. I turned around and asked - 'what are you talking about?'

One - a young doctor - told me that he'd had an idea. He'd spent a lot of time playing GeoQuest on facebook (disclosure: I love that game) and had discovered, to his surprise, that he'd developed a lot of geography knowledge by doing so. That set him thinking - 'anatomy is hard, games are fun, you learn from games, so why not teach anatomy with a game?' 

With no knowledge of the industry, the technical standards or anything else, this industrious group of clever young people were planning to create their own elearning resources for their peers. I could have cried, it was so touching. 

I gave them some hints, and left them with my email in case they wanted a hand. But the thing that got to me was this: that elearning made enough sense to these folk that they were willing to draw on their expertise, have a go, and make some themselves.

I salute them, and I hope to see many more.

Friday, 10 April 2009

I made a wonderful discovery yesterday.

I was cycling home after some volunteer work at a local primary school (nb: my day usually doesn't resemble Mary Poppins' quite so closely) when I accidentally found a new aquarium store: http://www.cambridgecoraltech.co.uk/.

I have dreamed of a store like this. Never thought I'd find one.

They sell coral. They sell lovely normal tropical fish. They also sell banded coral shrimp, lionfish, seahorses, pipefish, stonefish (OH MY GOD), stingrays (OH WOW) and - are we ready? SEA JELLIES.

Sea jellies! No way.

Sea jellies are super-hard to keep. They need constantly moving water and very specific foods. (The jellies on sale are apparently quite easy, becuase they like to lie upside down on their bells with their tentacles floating upwards. Nature, eh?)

Now why didn't I find this store before?

Because the browse mechanism that lead me to it was 'cycling down the right street'.

I've been intrigued for a while now by how bad conventional search is for finding local businesses. Location specificity in search is being improved by google maps, but there's a long way to go.

What excites me about improvements to location based search is this: That it will have a huge, and positive, impact of local small business. If a quick search can reveal that there is a specialist alternative to B&Q or homebase nearby, then that is more business that the specialist can potentially get, which in turn will lead to more specialists.

I could be wrong. But I hope that, if location based search gets really good, we could have a small-business renaissance. And wouldn't that be nice?


Ambiently

I quite like this.

In a conventional, keyword based search engine (I'm looking at you, Google) there's a lot of guess-work involved. It works like this:
  • There is a 'thing' out there in the world that can be described many ways using 'words'. (And yes, this remains true when the 'thing' is made of 'words', as the majority of open-web 'things' are.)
  • There is the author of a website. She describes her 'things' using certain 'words'.
  • There is a user. She must guess which 'words' the author used to describe the 'thing'.
For top-level concepts, that works fine. Take the educational content-packaging standard called 'SCORM'. Search using word SCORM, and you'll find a bunch of sites about SCORM. So far so good.

But if your search is more specific, it gets tricky. Let's say the user has a SCORM package and she'd like a free piece of software to test it for compliance to the SCORM 2004 specification. Now she has to guess words: 'free' 'compliance' 'SCORM' '2004' (bearing in mind that google uses whitespace as a delimiter - i.e. a way of breaking up English into meaningful chunks). Lots of results, but no testing tool! So she guesses again. And again. And again.

Ambiently provides a simple, but potentially very poweful, change. Via a button on the toolbar, it will present the user with 'related websites'. Instead the user guessing keywords, ambiently (I'm guessing based on my own limited trials, here) uses the site you're currently in as keywords. Start in the almost-right-place, and it will show you what's close. No guessing.

It's a small change. It's not semantic (my standard test of semantic value - 'piracy' - returned as much on copyright as it did on high seas crime). You won't see substantially different results from google. But I suspect that for intricate and/or highly specific searches, it will prove extremely useful.

Also - it brands itself as a 'discovery' engine, rather than a 'search' engine. Full props to that - it's about time we stopped using 'search' as a catch-all term for discovery. 'Search' implies that you already know exactly what you're looking for, denying the value of serendipitous discovery. Sure, it's semantics, but semantics are the bread and butter of content discovery!

www.ambiently.com

...and the answer to the question is: there is an excellent free SCORM compliance tool at www.scorm.com. If you use SCORM, this site is invaluable.

Sunday, 5 April 2009

Unique identifiers that aren't

...This has been bothering me for some time.

Here are my top two contenders for the most irritating 'unique identifiers that aren't'. By that I mean: terms that should refer to only one entity within a range of entities, but don't. 

If you search for 'Apple' on the open web (e.g. in Google), then yes, you will get a combination of fruit and tech. That's annoying, but the two entity sets - 'fruit' and 'tech' - are fundamentally different. If you move to an environment that serves a specific entity set - a supermarket online service, or cNet - that if you search 'apple' you'll get the relevant entity.

But what if there were two tech companies called 'Apple'? Entities with the same name in the same entity set? Well, of course, there are. Here are my least favourite:

1. Place names. 

I live in a town called 'Cambridge'. It is in the UK. There is also a town called 'Cambridge' in Massachusetts, USA. More annoyingly, they both have prestigious universities (in the US, Harvard). Searches on the open web usually return both.

It's not a big problem for me, but I have undying sympathy for the good people of Paris, Texas, and Melbourne, Florida. (The Paris people especially - they must curse that movie).

Still - country filters usually sort this one out without much fuss. Unlike...

2. People names.

My name is Zoe Rose.  A google search for "Zoe Rose" (mini google hack: double quotes tell the engine to search for the words as a string, i.e. disallowing the whitespace delimiter) will return, in reverse order:
  • Style A to Zoe by Rachel Zoe, Rose Apoda Apodaca by Little...
  • Zoe Rose Mogan Jennings
  • Zoe Rose - London | Facebook
  • Motel @ Topshop Urban Outfitters Zoe Rose Dress M 10 12 on eBay
  • Zoe Rose Designs - Hereford textile artist creating handmade...
  • Video result: Piedemont High School Senior Speaker Zoe Rose
  • bebo.com - Profile from Zoe Rose.
  • bebo.com - Profile from Zoe Rose
aaaaand, my personal favourite, result number one:
  • Zoe Rose - Actress. World Sex Tour 23: England. Visit IMDn for photos, filmography...
That's right. A porn star stole my name. 

You have to get to the third page before 'Zoe Rose' meaning me comes up at all - and the reference is way out of date. While it's nice to have some privacy, there is something cringeworthy about being outranked by a dress. 

So let's disect. My unique identifier is muddled up with: 
  • People who have part of my name - google can't differentiate between 'Rose' as middle name and 'Rose' as surname
  • Inadvertent co-location of 'Zoe' and 'Rose', due to rose being a proper noun as well as a name
  • People who legitimately have the same name as me (fair enough)
  • Entities that aren't people at all (the dress)
  • A porn star who I really, really wish had picked a different pseudonym
I can't think of a solution to this one. But I really hope someone else does - and soon.