Saturday, 14 August 2010

Inception: I think I've cracked it

Ok. I could be wrong, but I *think* I've worked out Inception. Which is to say - there is an answer, and this might just be it. Naturally, the following contains spoilers.

If you can prove me wrong, please do.


Here we go...

1. Cobb is dreaming for the entire movie.

2. Cobb is not the protagonist. Mal is.

3. Because we are watching Cobb's dream, we never actually meet Mal. This is a movie where we never meet the main character.

4. All the characters but Cobb - including Cobb's version of Mal - are dreamed by Cobb. All the things that happen are events dreamed by Cobb. Consequently - the entire movie is a McGuffin.

5. No, all of it. It's all a McGuffin.

6. It's a McGuffin because it's the story Cobb's unconscious has made up to protect itself. But one real thing did happen -

7. Cobb and Mal were indeed stuck in limbo together.

8. She got out.

9. He didn't - he's still there.

10. (Brace yourselves)

11. He didn't plant the suicide idea in her. She planted it in him. She did the inception.

11.5 Consider - on whose word do we have it that Cobb did the inception? Cobb's. We see them both reciting the lines about waiting for a train, but we never see anyone say it for the first time.

12. It didn't work.

13. Because inception doesn't work.

14. It's because Cobb's drive to be the protagonist was so strong that he couldn't accept the incepted idea, or with it, the truth that she was right the whole time, and that he was the one living in the not-real world. The story was made up by his subconscious as a way to protect him from the idea that he wasn't the protagonist.

15. That drive - to be the protagonist - was, in the story-pattern used by mainstream movies, masculine.

16. The movie was pulling an act of inception on you - planting the idea that the woman might be the agent, the protagonist. Female agents do not happen in our mainstream movies, our stories. The movie is a story about our stories and our stories are gendered. The story world were the men are always the protagonists, that is a not-real world. Those stories are not good for us. They're keeping us stuck in not-real thinking. We need better stories now.

17. It won't work.

18. Because inception doesn't work.

26 comments:

  1. Not seen the movie so can't comment on the main part (although I'll note that point 15 is really begging the question), but I had to reply to the sentence "Female agents do not happen in our movies, our TV, our stories."

    Now, granted, strong female agent characters are too rare, but they're not absent. X-Files had one, as did Middleman (both genre). I could even cite Chuck. Or (of all things) Torchwood.

    The main thrust of point 16, I agree with. The best stories don't deal with men - but nor do they deal with women, I'd suggest. They deal with people in all their splendid diversity.

    ReplyDelete
  2. John - I'll grant you x-files (now reaching 20 years old), Chuck (with caveats, namely that Sarah is a backup character), Torchwood (with the caveat that Moffat-related productions are natural rule-crackers), but honestly, I've never even heard of Middleman. Wikipedia tells me it ran one series. I note these are all TV shows. And that there still aren't that many. (Honourable mention to the massively underrated 'Dollhouse' here, too.)

    I like TV way more than movies, because TV has more room for complexity and nuance than movies (largely because there's just more time available). But you've got a point - I should have restricted the scope. If we just go for 'mainstream movies', the point holds. I've edited to reflect.

    On point 15 - yup, you're right. I've edited it. (The original reads 'that drive - to be the protagonist - was masculine'.)

    On point 16 - Totally, 100% with you. My question (and I think the question of the film) is, if the best stories are about people then why are all the core people in the mainstream movies men?

    Coda 1: Ever read Watchmen? To me, this film *smacked* of Watchmen. Half the point of Watchmen was to destroy superhero books by showing that superhero stories don't actually work. Inception, I think, was pulling a similar gambit with male-protagonist-only movie story types.

    Coda 2: Are you familiar with the Bechdel test? It's scary as anything: http://bechdeltest.com/

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think you veered off the course.

    Cobb said that he wasn't able to host the dream -- that it had to be Arthur (Joseph Gordon-Leavitt). Therefore, even if this is a dream, this is all Arthur's dream. Cobb, and Mal, are just in it.

    I think Cobb is actually Arthur. The part of Arthur that Arthur firewalls from himself. This could be for any reasons but the one that comes to mind is that it is Arthur who is in Limbo.

    I enjoy the chain of thought you have here, Zoe, but I am clearly not as sensitive to the whole "female can be a protagonist" challenges that are expressed here. I watch a whole lot of movies with women as the agents of story, heroes and villains alike. This is not to say that you don't have a point -- I'm just noting that it was not my read into the film at all. That said, I think that's what makes it such a good film is that it enables us to project and to question, our frames and constructs onto its canvas.

    Since it's Arthur's dream, every other character is either generated by his imagination or is a projection by Arthur taken from people in his real life.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Oooooh. Arthur was having the dream. Oooh that is nice.

    I'm going to do some straight rebuttal, logic only, first. If my theory is right then Arthur has to be a projection of cobb's. Cobb says that he can't create, but if I'm right and it's cobb's dream, then Cobb's assessment is wrong. Cobb says he can't create because of the threat of Mal interfering, and if you think that Cobb's projection of Mal includes the incepted idea of suicide, then that is a false belief that is protecting Cobb's ego as per the original theory.

    I'm intrigued as to what the evidence is for it all being Arthurs dream, can you flesh it out? It looks promising, I just can't quite get there...

    Onwards to - scary word - the feminist bit. Very, very hard to get a good objective take on ladies in movies. Let me introduce you yo the horror of the Bechdel test.

    It's not a test for if a movie is good, just if it has women in it. There are three criteria:

    1. It has two or more women in it.
    2. They have names.
    3. They talk to each other, at least once, about something other than men.

    There's not many mainstream movies that pass this test. Reverse the gender, they all pass.

    Start applying the test, and the problem becomes much bigger than we've become accustomed to thinking it is. And IMO, it's not good enough.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Clearly I need to watch the movie again now to gather supporting evidence for my theory. That was the lingering question I walked away with when I saw the film... but I must admit that I take Christopher Nolan's intentions clearly as the film itself -- I've tried not to read in any more mystery or hidden meaning to it (unlike Lost for the past five years).

    I'll have to start applying the Bechdel test, though my movie tonight, The Runaways, will surely pass.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Movies are certainly far worse offenders than TV when it comes to gender roles, and other things. (But if you've never seen Middleman, I'll have to lend you the DVDs. Hilarious, and geeky as anything. :-) Realised, too, that I even forgot Buffy in the TV list! Shameful.)

    I have seen Watchmen and, TBH, wasn't terribly impressed. It just tried too hard. I need to read the original comic book, I think. That film may have suffered because I ended up seeing Kick-Ass first, which (IMO) is weirdly a better film.

    The Bechdel Test, yes - my wife introduced me to it a while back. Scary stuff indeed!

    ReplyDelete
  7. @John - confession time. I wrote my undergraduate English honours thesis on 'Watchmen'. As a general rule, it's not a great idea to Get Me Started.

    The movie was fine, but it wasn't the book. The point of the book was dual: 1. By taking superhero stories to their logical conclusion (a truly super-powered person (Dr Manhattan/Superman) has no particular reason to act human, dark brooders (Rorschach/Batman) are crazy and dangerous, violence is horrible etc.) it showed that the superhero mythos was bankrupt and should not be used any more. 2. By being Extraordinarily Amazing, it showed that comics were a proper art form being sorely let down by reliance on superheroes.

    That's a comment on the art form, so can't translate to a different art form, hence the movie is just a story & can't be as amazing as the original.

    Link = Watchmen was a comic book about what's wrong with comic books + what's possible in comic books, Inception IMO is a movie about what's wrong with movies + what's possible in movies. Again, IMO.

    Totally with you about TV (and I *love* TV). Read a good analogy - movies are short & are designed to be absorbed in one sitting, TV shows are long & have to be absorbed over time. That's the same diff as between a short story and a novel. I love short stories, but for intellectual oomph I'll pick a novel every time :)

    Would love to see Middleman - dvd borrowage please!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Yes - once you're aware of the Bechdel test, you can never watch movies the same way again.

    Perhaps I'm a bit sensitive though - about twice a month I will have a brain explosion about BBC comedy shows I do like (mock the week, have I got news for you etc) because 99% of the time there will be 5 guys and one woman at most, and after editing, she's often barely there.


    Would just clarify Zoe's definition above though:

    1. It has to have at least two women in it
    2. Who talk to each other
    3. About something besides a man

    http://bechdeltest.com/

    ReplyDelete
  9. Gosh, a lot to talk about there.

    I love your interpretation of Inception, and as it stands I think it's sound - in that it can't be broken down or disproven.

    One of the things I love about movies like Inception is that, by stimulating the imagination in the way they do - something that should be universal in cinema, but sadly isn't - they have potential to be re-interpreted or the subject of endless thought experiments by the viewer.

    (Okay, fandom has shown that this can be done with ANY entertainment artifact, but it's easier to do with a piece that can be intellectual invested in.)

    The distinction I make here is one I'm fond of, best represented by something Warren Ellis said about Deadwood - He suggested that the next time you watch the show, you imagine that Al Swearengen is the hero, and Seth Bullock the villain. By looking at it askew, you can see things you wouldn't normally.

    While your reading is a really stimulating approach to the film, and has got me thinking about it again, I can't reconcile it with a more literal reading of it. Mostly because it requires an assessment of Christopher Nolan's intentions that isn't completely borne out by the narrative, or his past work.

    (For what it's worth, I don't think any of the theories about it ALL being a dream jibe with what's up on the screen.)

    I think Nolan had a deeper agenda than making a high-concept blockbuster, for sure - actually, a notion was working the back of my brain as I watched the film, that you've totally brought out here, because I think that Watchmen catch you made is a perfect way of putting it... Moore was writing the ultimate superhero book by destroying the superhero book, and I think Nolan was heading in that direction here, too.

    There's also a thread running through Nolan's movies, here - certainly his non-Batman movies: ALL of them contain pretty straight forward stories that over the running time are actually defined quite literally.

    Nolan's MO as a film-maker seems to be to play with an audience's narrative expectations, and pull wonder and surprise out of that. It's probably pretty obvious that I see The Prestige as the ultimate expression of this - I think Nolan's the Derren Brown of cinema, parading the facts of his story right in front of you, and challenging himself to trick you anyway.

    Breathe, Nick, breathe.

    Sorry, this stuff excites me.

    But I see Inception as a pretty direct movie. It's designed to try and shake you off - and I think it's actually not quite as adept as this as his earlier films - but for me there are clear narrative cues that what we are seeing is a sequence of dreams sitting inside dreams, with a "reality" bookending them.

    First up is the different textures of each dream - as well as obviously being Nolan's sublimated desire to make a Bond movie - that snowbound fortress is a total environmental and tonal contrast to the ordered and relatively quiet pace of the hotel sequence, or the urban reality of the wet city. Arthur solves puzzles, whereas Eames zips around and shoots shit.

    The changing textures, and the swapping protagonists in these dreams suggests multiple dreamers to me - while it could be argued that a single dreamer like Cobb might be capable of such variety, it's not suggested in the text...

    ReplyDelete
  10. ...(An interesting trick that Nolan pulls is in having what I see as the alpha reality be the only place that really retains that staccato continuity of a dream - I'm thinking specifically of the alley that seems to shrink, and the sudden cut to the university with Miles.

    At the time I thought Nolan was having a laugh here, deliberately playing the audience, but actually it's suggested that Cobb finds dreams more real than reality by this point.

    Thoughts piling on thoughts - this prime reality is the only place where cause/effect relationships aren't clearly and repeatedly outlined for us, which suggests to me that that's because reality isn't built and managed, but chaotic and uncertain.)

    That actually raises another issue with the notion that it's all Cobb's dream, rather than us looking in on a broader narrative - we see a lot of the movie through other people's eyes, without Cobb present, and the medium tells us that that means it's happening apart from him. Nolan isn't above bending narrative rules, but he's pretty rigid about not breaking them. If he did, Stephen King and I would call that cheating.

    There are arguments against this. One is that every character is Cobb - something you touch on - but I don't buy that... it requires us to step outside of the rules as we understand them, both from dreaming ourselves and what the movie tells us they are. A movie can play around with totally constructed delusions - Brazil and Fight Club are hopefully by now spoiler-free examples - but if we don't require the reveal as proof that it happened, we can't take ANYTHING at face value.

    I've been other people in my dreams, and I've observed scenes as if remotely, but we're given no reason to believe that's what's happening within the movie. Actually, one of the only issues I had with the movie was the relative stability and coherence of the dreams, but I can forgive that as a piece of production pragmatism, as "real" dreams would have made the film incomprehensible!

    I also think that the inclusion of the scene with old Saito at the beginning - which I felt was one narrative wrinkle too far at the time - is there specifically to tell you that outside of the disorientation of the dreams-within-dreams, you're also watching a film and a story, with it's own borders, rules, and architect. That tends to pin me down to more literal readings of the film. But I guess isn't an argument as such.

    I probably shouldn't be paid attention to on this subject, by the way: I believe absolutely both that the top falls at the end (you can hear it go after the picture does, and I don't think Nolan left that audio in by mistake) and that as a totem it is irrelevant anyway.

    Funnily enough, I actually thought the female characters in the movie are a little transparent. Mal, albeit as a construct of Cobbs, is mostly seen raging and homicidal or in voice-over flashback, and Ellen Page seems largely there as an exposition tool, though she's a good enough actress, and scripted well enough, that it never bothers you.

    Having said all that, I think as an academic reading of the movie, yours would work. While I don't think it's as literal as it all going on in Cobb's head, everything you say about his need to be the protagonist - and Arthur's, and Eames', each of them getting their own little action movie - and Ariadne's role as solver of the more intricate, cerebral of puzzles, her restraint and her decision to submit to the team - ring true to me...

    ReplyDelete
  11. ...As far as female leads go, I don't think there's a lack of them in Hollywood, it's just the ones that exist tend to be romantic idealism of appalling extremes - either they're all about a woman getting her man, or they're about a woman transcending reliance on men. One way or another, "The Proposal" and "Eat, Pray, Love" are still playing into a notion of what women want that has as much to do with what women actually want as the movie "What Women Want".

    My point is, there's obviously money in female-centric movies - the problem isn't a lack of them, so much as the delusion that Hollywood has about what they should be about.

    IF it's a delusion. If these movies didn't make money, they wouldn't get made, and my instinct is that it isn't men paying money for them.

    And I struggle with the Bechdel test. It feminises an issue that is actually universal, I think.

    The roots of it are flawed, is my problem, because they're entirely a side-effect of that tendency by Hollywood to make that distinction between which movies play to male audiences, and which ones play to female ones. Because the assumption is that women want movies about relationships, and all dialogue must drive forward the plot in Hollywood, those women are going to talk about men. The assumption is that men want action and plot - OH DEAR GOD OH SO MUCH PLOT - so the men tend to gravitate toward near autistic levels of directness in their conversations, and if they diverge from that, it's to make geek-centric analogies (and by geek I mean ALL MANNER of geek, from football to movies to comics to whatever), but the shallowness of them is consistent.

    So a companion test to seeing if there are women who talk about something other than a man would be to see if there are men who talk about anything even approximating their emotions.

    My problem with Bechdel is that it's generally considered okay to see the first as a problem, but somehow the latter isn't identified as such. Both fly just fine with the majority of audiences, and that speaks to a broader cultural issue - one that can be reduced to "how come people keep putting Jennifer Aniston/Hayden Christensen in movies?"

    I... keep thinking of more stuff to say, but that's probably plenty for now. Needless to say, great post!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Tasty treats...

    Can't type properly on the iPad so the full response tomorrow.

    ReplyDelete
  13. First: Ten billion geek points if you can source the quote 'tasty treats'.

    Second: I'm of the opinion that it *was* all a dream (as per the post). If you can show me any example of non-dream state, go ahead.

    Third: Nolan really has a thing for killing the lady love interests, have you noticed? Memento, Batman (didn't like it btw), this... it's a recurrent theme. I do think that Inception was a form of explanation for all those dead ladies.

    Fourth: Yeah, you're right. Breaking the rules is cheating, and Nolan doesn't cheat. And scenes *without* the protagonist in if he's dreaming would be cheating. That's the kicker that my analysis isn't at the 100% mark.

    Fifth: If my assessment is correct, then Mal HAS to be raging and homocidal - if she wasn't, he'd have to listen to her, right? And Ariadne is just normal enough that you don't suspect her of being a figment - just normal enough, but no more. Exactly what Cobb's ego would require.

    Sixth: I will buy your take on the Bechdel test when you can show that it applies equally to men. It doesn't. Not your fault, not mine, all the fault of the money holders who believe that the lowest common denominator actually exists.

    All hail the rise of user generated content.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I can't source the quote "tasty treats". I couldn't even find it with Google (guessing you're not talking about donut related sex-acts). I could ask Twitter, but you'd notice, and I suspect that invalidates the attempt... Where's it from??

    Heh, well, your theory is pretty watertight, in that there is no way to prove that any of it wasn't a dream. DAMMIT. It's the same problem one has with discussing the existence or non-existence of God - it's impossible to prove, because that's the nature of the ineffable, but it's impossible to disprove, because THAT'S the nature of the ineffable, too.
    Personally, I think the nature of dreaming in Inception is more important.

    (And I err on the side of small "a" atheism, not that you're asking!)

    There is no way to prove that the bracketing reality is the real one, beyond saying that to me, narratively, that gels best with the rest of the movie - most especially the very cinematically artificial elements such as the out of sequence flashforward with Old Saito, the scenes without Cobb in, and if I'm particularly picky, the bits of the movie where we actually see flashbacks as he tells the story, which aren't actually very immersive or dreamlike - those all tell me that Nolan wants us to experience this story as a story - that despite it being in such a surreal setting he's setting out a broad narrative rather than one person's immersive dreamscape, and anything else feels like a trick too far, and one that risks undermining what I think Nolan's thesis is.

    (It didn't fit in that paragraph, and I think I need to see the movie on DVD to see how notieable this is, but because of the visual blurring of the final scene I reckon he could have got away with using the same child actors for Cobb's children, and no-one would be any the wiser, but he made the choice to go with older actors. That doesn't PROVE that there was genuine continuity going on there, and it's not beyond Cobb to mentally age the kids, but again, it doesn't fit with the rest of the narrative or any of the other rules that are laid out.)

    Admittedly, I think one of the points Nolan is making is that, when there can be so little difference between dreams and reality, the distinction maybe isn't as important as we choose to think. I also believe that the plot point isn't whether the top spins or falters, but that Cobb no longer cares to check. Nolan purposefully leaves us there, but his protagonist moves on.

    I hadn't thought of the dead lady thing before. I wonder if the recurrent theme is dead ladies, or emotionally isolated and guilt-wracked men?

    (From a comic geek point of view, I enjoyed both Batmen, but I think they're flawed movies, where his auteur stuff isn't so much.)

    You're right about Mal - both of us agree she's a figment of Cobb's subconscious. I think she's both the result of his denial - as you'd have it - and his self-loathing guilt... he believes he should be punished for what he did to her, so she punishes him.

    More I think about it, I think that the non-protagonist scenes are insurmountable in any Cobb's dream theory, because there are so many of them - thinking about several moments between Arthur and Ariadne. ONLY way to explain it is to say that each one of them is a different facet of his character, but they're all so advanced, and it's never suggested that we're watching THAT sort of movie. As presented, it's a "dream" movie, not a "subconscious mind" one.

    (That sort of movie, by the way, is Identity, which I quite dug.)

    ReplyDelete
  15. Hmmmm, I've not seen inception. But I have seen Christopher Nolan's graduation film and Memento, so from those I could posit the following conjecture: he writes films thay are either recursive or iterative. They both lack a definitive end in narrative, and are effectively chronologically truncated / attentuated pieces - the story is, to paraphrase Debussy, abandoned, but not finished.

    Ergo, I would suggest, the end was not the end, and the start was not the start. Does this shed any new light?

    As for the watchmen, I don't think it's about how superheroes act. I think it's almost a criticism of the Nietseczhe (sp?) concept of Ubermensch. Whereas your run of the mill superheroes are all positive models to people (ish), and so could receive some form of fandom, each superhero in the watchmen is designed solely to alienate. Take Rorshach - derived from 'the answer'. Key change, the question mark face mask becomes the almost repellent blots. It's designed to prevent relation to the character, almost like say, Brechtian theatre does?

    Your atypical superhero has powers, all Rorshach has (i can't spell) is his vague unstability and slightly confused morality. He is probably the most normal superhero there is.

    So within the story, are events, and characters who actions say "you are not us" and "do not rely on us". So even when they trigger armageddon to prevent wwIII, it is seen as acceptable to them. We only know the story almost be accident, because of the diary. The diary almost works as a leak, a secret glimpse into the system which reveals it's falacies.

    But i'd agree, comics are art, and most superhero tales are crap. From Hell is awesome.

    ReplyDelete
  16. H'okay, so, to kick off. Bechdel's test seems flawed to me, if only 'cause there's the annoying, literal truth that if there's only 1 woman in a movie, there's still a woman in a movie. Also, even if all the 2 hypothetical women talk about in a movie is men, they're still, it can't be avoided, IN THE MOVIE (pls read those shouty caps as emphatic italics, typing with iPhone).

    Regarding the whole "it's all a dream argument, I think I agree with pretty much everything Nick said (especially the whole "Nolan wants to make a Bond film" thing, thought exactly the same thing as they were skiing across the snow to the sound of a musical sting).

    I think if he was still dreaming then we'd never see the kids' faces, as that was the cut-off point in all his dream moments with them (think 'you can't turn around to see what's chasing you in a nightmare' or 'you don't hit the ground in a falling dream').

    The bits with other characters are also a big point. Many if them, Cobb wasn't idle somewhere else, allowing his mind to wonder, he was engaged in conversation/action/inception elsewhere. Granted, the sub con guards for rich boy kept coming when he was elsewhere, but they were simplistic constructs... although the not-Eames Tom Berenger was able to converse, so maybe that argument doesn't count...

    ReplyDelete
  17. I would agree with what you appear to be saying, Zoe, that TV is consistently doing more interesting things than film right now, esp. in relation to narrative & character (Breaking Bad, Sons Of Anarchy, Weeds & Walking Dead, anyone?) and has been for a while now (The Wire, The Shield, Lost, Deadwood & The Sopranos, anyone?) or, to put it another way (& paraphrase the Comedy Film Nerds [a great podcast, BTW]), why watch a gritty cop movie when you can watch 2 episodes of The Shield back to back & get a better story and, most likely, better acting?

    Going back to your Inception theory, and to repeat what I said on FB & (I think) paraphrase Nick's point, I think your reading is a perfectly valid & mostly defensible academic interpretation of the text, but I don't think it's entirely accurate from a narrative POV.

    ReplyDelete
  18. For my next trick ...

    Aliens
    The Peacemaker
    Mr & Mrs Smith
    The Shield (the Glenn Close season specifically)
    Resident Evil
    Kill Bill
    Lethal Weapon 3
    Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon (may not count, as not a Western film)
    Spaced
    Twister
    Beaches
    Driving Miss Daisy
    Sister Act
    Jurassic Park
    Silence of the Lambs

    Just a few EGs of narratives with driving, protagonist female characters and if, for EG, one argues Kill Bill doesn't count, given the instigator of the plot is male, then the arguments along the lines of "it's all about the masculine" also break down 'cause many of their plots are instigated by women.

    I'd much rather have this argument in person, though. I work out my thoughts by speaking through them & so I apologise if what I've here seems half-baked

    ReplyDelete
  19. Dang it! Couldn't scroll up/down in post on iPhone. I also wanted to say that I completely agree there aren't enough female protagonists, just that they are out there if you look and, again, I think Bechdel's test is too simplistic.

    Also;

    Dogma
    Scream
    Starship Troopers
    True Grit (both versions, I think)
    Police Academy
    Long Kiss Goodnight
    Thomas Crown Affair (shit film, valid example)
    Gone In 60 Seconds (in fact, most everything Ms Jolie has done)
    The Mummy
    Enemy At The Gates
    Mulan (altho perchance her pretending to be a bloke cancels this one out?)

    Like I said, not saying female protagonists are presented as often or as prominently as they should be, but they are out there.

    ReplyDelete
  20. @Euan - OK I will pay your examples, but I think this falls into what I call 'the happy prostitute' fallacy.

    There is such a thing as a happy prostitute. There are folk who love being prostitutes, who even think of it as their vocation. That is totally, 100% true.

    But the thing is, there are so damn few of them that it doesn't really make a difference - they're real, they're just statistically insignificant. Most prostitutes are totally miserable and don't want to be doing that work.

    The exception doesn't prove the rule (especially because that particular phrase comes from old English, when 'prove' actually meant 'test'). So while the examples are valid, I just don't think they count.

    In other news, I <3 Ripley so much. So very, very much. I have considered calling my firstborn girl Ellen... but she'll probably be called Selina instead ;)

    ReplyDelete
  21. Oo! Is there any chance of having a read of that WATCHMEN thesis?

    (I haven't read the rest of this discussion yet, I wanted to say that before the idea fell out of my head!)

    ReplyDelete
  22. I confess I've only seen INCEPTION the once, and that was an interrupted viewing. So I'm not sure what I make of some of it as I'm not sure it all went in yet.

    I think if it's (say) Cobb's dream, then having scenes without Cobb isn't necessarily 'cheating'. Dreams, as the film points out (sort of), are weird. I've certainly had dreams that have had parts where I haven't been there.

    I noticed the 'narrowing' alleyway too (from an outside-the-story point of view, I also noticed that it probably wasn't really that difficult to fit Leonardo through that gap, but that's another matter). I wondered at the time if that meant that part was a dream. (Or that architecture there is rubbish.)

    Anyway, onto Zoe's main theory. I don't know if it's how I now see the film but I don't think I see any major flaws in it. If Cobb is indeed dreaming, then it makes sense that so many things are All About Him. Inception is impossible, but he says/thinks/knows he can do it. He's the one with huge stakes in the reverse-heist. He gets to stop being on the run and go home and see his children and whathaveyou. The others have money on the line, but for the most part if they said 'no', they could just get on with their lives. (Unless Saito's concerns about a new superpower are genuine and founded, but that's less immediate and personal.)

    With this theory, would Cobb unconsciously know that Mal made it out? Or would he on every level wholeheartedly believe that they both got out and she later killed herself?

    ReplyDelete
  23. Tangents again...Selina? Does that name come from where I hope it does?

    ReplyDelete
  24. I think the Bechdel test is based on the idea that women simply being 'in the movie' isn't enough.

    That said, I've often wondered about some of the details that must go with the test? What about unknown identities or entities that are later discovered to be male? Or are simply not known? Or collectives, such as 'the police'?

    All this is dearly making me want that enormous book of hers that's at my local comic shop...

    ReplyDelete
  25. Daria - I think Cobb *does* know that Mal made it out. That's what's chasing him, the knowledge of the truth in her body, and why he has to keep running away from it.

    And yup - that name comes from *exactly* where you think it does :)

    ReplyDelete
  26. Having just rewatched, I present the following alternative theory:

    The film is all a dream, but one dreamt by Miles.

    Cobb killed Mal, in real life, having himself been driven mad by the dream-tinkering in which he and Mal were involved. Miles is attempting an act of auto-inception, hoping to impose a contrived redemption narrative onto Cobb to restore meaning and purpose to a world suddenly bereft of both.

    Here's proof:

    * The film strongly suggests that Miles is himself a genius architect, and perhaps the originator of the whole concept/technique of dream invasion.

    * Despite this, Miles remains in the wings, reflecting his own need to distance himself from Cobb's deed.

    * In his first appearance, he introduces Ariadne (on whom more below), effectively producing her ex nihilo, who is key to Cobb's redemption.

    * His only other appearance is at the end of the film, to enjoy the successful conclusion of the redemption narrative.

    * The dream-world fails the Bechdel test and is full of ridiculous action scenes and panning shots precisely because Miles is such a good architect: he has constructed a dream-world that perfectly matches the Hollywoodesque idea he seeks to implant.

    * The whole concept of 'inception' is projection of Miles' fear that he 'implanted' the idea of ever-deeper dream invasion into the minds of his daughter and son-in-law, and that this drove Cobb to madness. However, this was not an act of inception as conceived in the film, but more the desire of both to please the father(-in-law). The guilt that Cobb feels is similarly in part a projection of Miles' own guilt.

    * Ariadne is a surrogate for Mal. Clearly Miles has a paternal relationship with her (healthily conceived of as lecturer to student in his dream), and like Mal she is a talented architect - crucially, perhaps, better than Cobb. Unlike Mal, however, she is able to keep Cobb from crossing the brink into madness, and she survives working with him; in this sense, then, she is an idealized Mal, who would not have died as Mal did.

    * Further to this, Ariadne reflects the overall point of the dream. At the start of the film Cobb is unpredictable and broody; no-one knows exactly what drives him and he is not co-operative, not a fully integrated member of his small gang. Through penetrating down to his true motives and feelings, Ariadne reveals a purposeful and meaningful reason for Mal's death, and paves the way for Cobb to become an integrated member of his family again.

    * However, Miles cannot bring himself to fully forgive Cobb. Although Cobb is exonerated from the actual murder, he retains a responsibility for Mal's death, through the act of inception.

    * Miles is Michael Caine. QED.

    ReplyDelete