Tuesday, 16 November 2010

Academic journals vs. public good vs. money


Fizzing. Fizzing with ideas!

I'm just back from an excellent Arcadia seminar on "Re-engineering the scholarly journal", by Mark Patterson, Director of Publishing, Public Library of Science.

If you haven't seen PLoS, check it out, it's awesome. Just look at what they've done with their metadata - look at it! Lovely. https://www.plos.org/

Short version - PLoS is (among other things) an open access academic journal repository for science. That means two things:

1. The content is free
2. You can do whatever you like with the content, as long as you attribute it.

Now I have many things to say about open access academic content (nutshell: I think it's great). But I'm going to talk about business models. Something I don't like about journal publishing is the trajectory of cash.

There are Four players:
  • Funding body
  • Researcher
  • Publisher
  • Reader
The sequence goes like this:
  1. Funding body given funding usually/often out of public funds (see also: the drug industry)
  2. Grant request submitted by researcher
  3. Grant request approved by funding body
  4. Money handed over by funding body
  5. Research done
  6. Research submitted for publication to publisher
  7. Publisher accepts for peer review
  8. Peer review
  9. Publisher publishes
  10. Library (usually university affiliated) pays for subscription to content
  11. Reader with library membership accesses content
OR (for the last two steps)

10. Reader pays for one-off access
11. Reader accesses content

Now this does my head in because of where the money changes hands. We start with public money (or, often enough that it counts), but we end with something that is not accessible to the public. Including the author!

The public can't use what they paid to create? That can't be right.

PLoS isn't like that, because PLoS doesn't charge for content. In PLoS, the public *can* use what they paid to create. But PLoS isn't a money sponge, it pays for itself - they're in 'surplus' (that's not-for-profit speak for 'profit') right now. How?

No really, how? How do you get in profit from not charging for content?

Well, they do it like this.

Consider those four players, in chronological reverse order this time:
  • Reader
  • Publisher
  • Researcher
  • Funding body
...now, who of these players have the most to gain from a single, individual piece of research hitting eyeballs? Who is the most fussed?
  • Reader: Seriously not fussed, just wants good content
  • Publisher: Semi-fussed, but only really cares about the aggregated eyeballs, not the individual articles
  • Researcher: Moderately fussed, but is probably more fussed about the name of the journal (a rant for another day - this is not a sufficient value metric)
  • Funding body: Pretty damn fussed.
Why is the funding body pretty damn fussed? Because the point of funding research is to have people read it. Without readers, the funding money is wasted. Results that are poorly disseminated may as well not exist.

What PLoS does is, they charge in accordance with fussedness. They charge the funding body.

Funding bodies pay for content to be published in PLoS. The cash-burden is thus neatly transferred from the end-user to the initiator. I'm not sure what it costs, but I do know that the funding bodies fork out. That means that the publisher can still generate a surplus/profit for their entirely necessary (and damn difficult) value-adding process of filtering, reviewing, aggregating, disseminating, and archiving, while the end-user can access what they did, after all, pay for, thereby increasing the sum total of knowledge in the universe.

What a great idea. Well done, PLoS. May you have many imitators.

Thursday, 14 October 2010

JISC transcoder

If you don't deal with SCORM, this post is not for you.

If you DO deal with SCORM, and you deal with packages that have to be deployed in multiple VLEs, today is your lucky day! Behold - the JISC transcoder!

Does what it says on the tin. It will convert your SCORM objects (including 1.2) to SCORM 2004, Common Cartridge 1.0, and IMS CP 1.1.4.

To the best of my knowledge, it's the only thing on the market like it - but it's not actually on the market, because it's free.

Enjoy!

Monday, 11 October 2010

Information and truth and information and truth

I'm not going to give you his name.

My husband and I were having lunch with a friend on the weekend, and the topic turned to business. My husband works in International law, and so does our friend, but at the sharp end. Specifically, our friend prosecutes war crimes.

'Before we go on,' he says, 'there's something I should probably tell you. I'm currently the subject of a criminal investigation.'

And the crime, as it turned out, was torture.

Now strange things happen in the world, and I'm cautious of any statement that reads 'I know X and he would never' (I've seen at least three stalkers - who really were stalkers - defended that way). But frankly, the odds against this being true would give the infinite improbability drive a run for it's money. The idea that some particularly knuckle-headed defendants tried a last-ditch move to get off the charges against them, on the other hand, is running at 1:1.0000000001 odds on the being-true front. But still.

If you google my friend, you'll find an article in a reputable UK newspaper with his name and the charges. I'm not linking to it, because no way am I going to push it up the google ranks. But it's turned me to thinking about the social impacts of truth.


True statement:

Friend has been accused of torture.

Totally legitimate newsworthiness:

High.


Highly-unlikely-to-be-true statement:

Friend committed the crime of torture.

Totally legitimate newsworthiness:
Absolutely none.


That's not a 'oh shame on you media' statement, it's a point of necessity: Probability statements aren't news, nor should they be (apart from op ed blarney). 'Bad accusation made against good dude who almost certainly did no such thing' is not legitimate news, because there's no fact content in it. 'He probably didn't' is not reportable, and if it was, a lot more bad people would get away with a lot more bad things.

And yet, and yet, and yet... there's also social truth. And longevity. Especially longevity.

Flash forward to the hasn't-happened-yet end of the criminal proceedings:


True statement:

Friend has been cleared of torture accusations.

True statement:

Friend did not commit torture.

Totally legitimate newsworthiness:

Middling.


Middling because nothing really happened. An allegation was disproved. That means the basic system of the world didn't *actually* change - a falsehood came up and was knocked down. Nothing actually new about the world was revealed, just a slight blip in the great long list of Things People Have Said - a list that does not have a 1:1 correlation with Things That Happened.

Again, this is not an 'I blame the media' statement - it's just that 'someone didn't do something' is, in most circumstances, far less interesting/useful knowledge than 'someone might have done something'.

(Some of you will know that I've done my time with journos, and I don't actually like the news media very much at all. So I am trying Extra Hard to be Totally Objective here.)


Flash forward two (hypothetical) years, and let's imagine two (I'm being optimistic here, there may be more) articles in reputable newspapers about this case exist online.
One contains time-sensitive true statement 1: 'X is accused of torture.'

The other contains non-time-sensitive true statement 2: 'X has been acquitted of torture.'


...Which of these will have the higher google ranking?

Which will more people see?

Given that both are true, which will the most people know to be true?

And of those that see only the first, how many will interpret 'accused of' as 'did'?


I don't have answers to this, and never in a million years would I say the first article should be taken down. I just worry about my friend, that a malicious move by bad people could follow him around for the rest of his life because the technology for 'true' doesn't meet the world's real requirements for 'true'.

But then again, he's seen worse.


Tuesday, 5 October 2010

Cheap wins



Pop quiz! What's the difference between these two statements:


1. For information about fish, click here

2. Click here for information about fish


Answer: If you're blind/vision impaired and using a screen reader (which reads the page aloud), and you opt for the handy/commonly used 'read me all the links on this page, please' option, they respectively read like this:





...out of those two, option one doesn't mean anything and option two does. That has to be about the simplest way to improve accessibility ever. (And it sounds better, too.)


e-learning and e-learning standards

I've finally done an annotated version of my Technical Communications UK conference presentation - and here it is:


(Warning: contains lots and lots of SCORM.)

Sunday, 3 October 2010

24 hour comic: Done.

I am Never Doing This Again.

I had a specific plan in doing a 24 hour comic (http://www.24hourcomicsday.com/) - specifically, challenging myself to do bad work. Completion over quality!

Why?

Because when I fall, I fall at the first hurdle, that's why.

There are a lot of benefits to planning projects properly (my go-to position). You get to Get It Right The First Time. You also Save Time in the Long Run. But if you can't get the plan sorted properly... splat! Down goes the whole thing - that's the first hurdle. That bit that comes after the plan. The doing-bit.

So I did a 24 hour comic to see if I could finish something with no plan at all - not just drawing it, but tracking it, uploading it, the works. And I did! And guess what? The comic is really pretty bad. But it's done! Yay!

Here it is: http://bit.ly/acHpxB


Things I learned from doing this

1. Set-up times still exist when you're working at high speed.

As a setting-up fan I always figured they were somehow optional/something I could not do if I chose, but no - turns out, even at break-neck speed there's still times involved here.


2. Pre-existing knowledge counts. A lot.

This would be impossible if I couldn't draw a bit first, but *equally* if I hadn't messed around with Tumblr before.


3. The urge to fiddle with things gets stronger the closer the finishing line is

I think this might be because the finishing line is scary - as long as it's incomplete, it can be fixed. Once it's out there, no chance - it will be it's own fairly poor thing. Submitting is *hard*, even when the goal is poor work.


4. I can drag a theme out of thin air if I have to

Surprise talent! I didn't script a word of the comic - just made it up page by page. But my buddy tells me it *looks* scripted, so, I'm happy with that.


5. Maudlin is really hard to avoid actually

I really hate the page where the two figments tease me. It is so twee & saccharine (but I couldn't use a replacement page, so I'm stuck with it). I did it because it was easy - twee is totally easy.


6. Everything takes longer than you think

The comic took ages. So did this post, actually. I keep editing it.


7. Stopping and not editing any more is hard

But, as a skill, it *can* be learned. I'll show you, ready?

It's like this:


Saturday, 2 October 2010

24 hour comics day

It's 24 hour comics day, and I am IN.

The deal is - 24 pages in 24 hours. That's it.

I've chosen to heighten the stakes a little - 24 pieces of paper (no spares), and really really bad pencils. Because I can't find my pencil case. (Great start, hey?)

Follow it all here:

www.zoedoesa24hourcomic.blogspot.com