Tuesday, 21 December 2010

Know your knowns

As I am on holidays, I'm catching up with the long list of 'things I've been meaning to blog about forever'. Today: Donald Rumsfeld.

"There are known knowns. These are things we know that we know. There are known unknowns. That is to say, there are things that we know we don't know. But there are also unknown unknowns. There are things we don't know we don't know."

- Donald Rumsfeld, 12 February 2002.

I hate to find myself defending the man, but this makes total sense - and it is a very powerful tool for knowledge management.

Let''s break this down. There are only two variables:
  • Known
  • Unknown
These two variables can be combined in only four ways:
  • Known Known
  • Known Unknown
  • Unknown Known
  • Unknown Unknown

Consider the potential applications as they relate to the knowledge held by a single person about "Bronywn's birthday"
  • Known known
    "It's Bronwyn's birthday tomorrow"
  • Known unknown
    "When is Bronwyn's birthday again?"
  • Unknown known
    "Crap! I forgot Bronwyn's birthday!"
  • Unknown unknown
    Bronwyn is actually a cylon, and therefore does not have a birthday.

...that's one person, but the same can apply to an organisation where knowledge is distributed across multiple brains - such as, for example, James Bond's nemesis organisation SPECTRE:

  • Known known
    (Everyone in the organisation knows what's going on)
    "Tomorrow we will hold the UN to ransom with our incredible Death Ray."
  • Known unknown
    (One+ person doesn't known something, but they know that someone else does know)
    "I can't find the keys to the Death Ray. Who has the keys? Come on, one of you guys has the keys..."
  • Unknown known
    (One person knows something, another person doesn't, but they don't know there's a disconnect)
    "The infra-dinfra-super-destructo setting isn't working, why isn't it working? Is it broken? I think it's broken." (It's not broken, the lead engineer turned it off on purpose because it was badly implemented and likely to explode/destroy the entire Headquarters.)
  • Unknown unknown
    Henchman #5 is actually James Bond. He has stolen the keys, invisibly set the infra-dinfra-super-desctructo setting to blow up in five minutes time, and is currently riding to freedom on the back of a robot dolphin.

Tuesday, 14 December 2010

Copyright in higher education is annoying

I'm going to go on ahead and pirate my own comments from Nicolas Steenhout's blog. I should point out here, however, that his post is better than mine - read it at http://accessibility.net.nz/blog/copyright-universities-course-content/

***************************************

It seems to me that there's actually a schism at the heart of copyright in HE lecture content. It goes like this:

1. The point of lectures is to communicate information to a large group of people

2. The thing that lecturers want least is to communicate information to a large group of people

The difference between the two is what constitutes the 'group' - in 1, it's students, in 2, it's everybody. The only truly efficient (current) mechanism for identifying students is 'people who are physically in the room when I talk', which is basically not good enough because it doesn't accommodate the bits of the lecture that aren't talking - handouts, slides, reading lists.

When it comes to the handouts/slides/reading lists, there's no group identification mechanism, so the lecturer relies on making accessing the content really, really annoying. Physically picking up printed copies of notes at the door of the lecture theatre, for example.

Making access annoying is exactly the opposite of making access accessible.

This is not a surface level problem - it's in the roots. I'm not at all sure what can be done to fix it, but if it does get fixed, it will have to be in the roots too.

***************************************

I wrote this about accessibility, but following a quiet mull, I don't think this is an accessibility problem - or rather, I don't think it's *only* an accessibility problem. The VLE was supposed to sort the access-for-students-only problem out, but it hasn't - VLEs are still barely useable environments that most lecturers don't like or - worse - understand.

That's not good. That's bad.

Very, very tentatively, could I maybe suggest that maybe, just maybe, HE should just loosen up a little about IP?


Thursday, 9 December 2010

Irritant

You know when you're looking for something, or you just found something you were looking for, someone always says 'it's always in the last place you look'?

That's because once you've found what you're looking for, you stop looking.

Let's all never use that phrase again, shall we?


coda: I should point out that 30 hour journeys with 11 hour time differences make me irritable. Apologies.

Tuesday, 7 December 2010

Memexer by request

Unbelievably, today I have had *two* people actually ask me to blog about stuff I've said on twitter. This is akin to saying 'that's very interesting' to a lawyer - you shouldn't do it, because they WILL TELL YOU MORE. And nobody wants that.


With that in mind...


The question of job titles for knowledge workers came up today. Everyone in (or near) the field know that this is sticky territory. The titles themselves are often meaningless, or so industry-specific/ambiguous you can't say what you do at a dinner party without sounding ridiculous. The language, sub-sets, actual fields of practice, they're all very amorphous both within and outside the knowledge worker community - about the only widely recognised job title in the bunch is 'librarian', and there aren't that many of them. It's useful in some ways, but there is enough ambiguity that charlatans (hello, 'social media experts') can creep into the system without raising any red flags. What is it, exactly, that we do? What is it called? What's the difference between my job and your job?


An analogy: Chronic fatigue syndrome.


There's definitely something going on with CFS. There are really real people who have terrible symptoms of constant fatigue ('syndrome' being 'a collection of symptoms'), who have been told by their Doctors that they have CFS. The thing the doctors call CFS can be life destroying.


...and then there are these other people who say they have CFS, some of whom have been diagnosed by doctors, others not so much, who are basically fine.


Here's my little point - no-one knows what CFS actually is.


Here's my big point - no-one knows how many things CFS actually is.


CFS is currently used as a blanket term for what is emerging as a whole spectrum of disorders. We have to use it as a definition, because there's no other more meaningful set of definitions available.


Talking about CFS under the current definition is like talking about 'headache', and assuming that 'headache' is a sufficiently good term to cover 'headache', 'migraine', 'hangover', 'brain cancer', and 'stroke'. But it isn't, which is why we have the terms 'headache', 'migraine', 'hangover', 'brain cancer', and 'stroke'. (Yes I know most brain cancers and strokes don't hurt, that's part of my point. Did you know there are no pain-receptor nerves in the brain? Surgery for Parkinsons is done under a local. Amazing. I digress.)


Here's what the NHS has to say about CFS:


Chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) causes long-term tiredness (fatigue) that affects everyday life. It does not go away with sleep or rest.

CFS is also known as ME, which stands for myalgic encephalomyelitis. Myalgia means muscle pain and encephalomyelitis means inflammation of the brain and spinal cord. Both terms are commonly used.

There is no cure for CFS, so treatment tends to focus on easing the symptoms. These include muscle pain and headaches.


http://www.nhs.uk/conditions/chronic-fatigue-syndrome/pages/introduction.aspx


Ambiguous, no?


That stretches from 'I get tired more and faster than other people' to 'I'm lazy but I'm down with blaming that on something other than myself' to 'I can't get out of my bed' (follow @stroopwaffle for someone facing this circumstance with dignity).


Clearly these people have different things going on. Clearly, some of them are suffering terribly, some a little, and some are self-deluding.But they all carry the same name. They all have - or say they have - CFS.


That means there's something wrong with the term 'CFS'.


But as of right now, the term CFS (along with it's sister-diagnosis ME) is still the best we have. And until something better comes along, it's still useful. For describing true sufferers, it's better than 'lazy', 'tired all the time', and 'sick', which are the only other options on the table.


We're finding out more about the conditions currently aggregated as CFS all the time - and the more we find out, the more it will get broken into useable, recognisable, identifiable chunks, things sufferers, doctors, and the public can understand and communicate with each other about. The better the definitions, the easier it will be to explain (not cure, unfortunately) and the less wiggle-room will be available for the charlatans.


The same goes for job titles when you're a knowledge worker. There's only one real difference: we don't have doctors. Doctors are experts in their field. We're the experts in our field. We're the doctors.


Knowledge work is not well-defined yet, and it's facets haven't been teased out. But if anyone is going to define us, if anyone is going to identify and communicate the different things that we are, it's probably going to be us.


Monday, 29 November 2010

Found it!

So I am, boringly, obsessed by search.

Not in an existential, meaning-of-life type of way, just finding stuff. On the internet. How it's organised, how the algorithms work, what filters are available and are they the right ones. That kind of thing.

The thing is, there was this movie. The premise of the movie is as follows: the electricity stops working. All of it. The tv, the radio, the cash machines, the cash registers. Phones. Boilers. Torches. Everything.

I saw it - most of it- as an undergrad, but I went to bed before the end.

Bad decision.

Ever since, I have wondered how that movie ended. And since then (I was an undergrad 1999 - 2002, including honours), search technology has gotten better and better. It's hard to think back that far - yahoo! may well have been the search leader at the time, I don't know. I've decided not to look it up, mostly to prove a point, though I'm not yet sure which point.

All I know about the movie is the premise, and something about a kid with an earache. No actors. No title. No idea when it was made.

I have literally (that's the literal definition of literally, by the way) been avoiding searching for this movie for years. Basically out of fear. Not the fear that I won't find the movie, more the fear that I can't find the movie. That either my search skills, or the search mechanisms, will be deficient. That, having started to look, I'll get sucked into a horrible vortex of either a) failing and giving up or b) (more likely) becoming obsessed and losing hours of my otherwise productive time to a fruitless enterprise of scooting around the internet, finding search mechanisms and typing variants on 'that one movie where the electricity stopped working and the kid got an earache and I think there was a gun'.

So tonight I finally tried to find it.

It took seven minutes.

I got there - unexpectedly - by searching 'electricity' on www.findanymovie.com, and clicking through to (only!) the second page. Then I checked the checked the potential title-match against www.imdb.com. (The search functionality on imdb is awful, by the way, although the summaries are good once you've found what you want.)

The movie is called "the Trigger effect". I have no idea if I recommend it or not.

But now that I've found it, I'm going to find out.

Saturday, 27 November 2010

Very niche hilarity

The wonderful Pat Lockley of the University of Nottingham (that's @patlockley, tweeps) made this extraordinary video about 'the Plight of Metadata':

http://vimeo.com/16908120

It's twenty minutes worth of pure gold, with a caveat - it's only funny if you know about standards-based metadata.

That's quite a niche. Personally, I made my colleagues fear for my mental health by watching this at work - I couldn't stop laughing.

I love the video, but on the broader scale, I love that the Miracle of the Internet can actually make it viable to create a film like this. Before the internet, I doubt this video would ever have been made, because there was no way to distribute it to the (admittedly small) number of people who would actually enjoy it and benefit from it.

Then again, before the internet there would be no need for the Dublin Core metadata profile either - so there you go.

Monday, 22 November 2010

Absolutely not.

RIGHT.

You. You know who you are. Yes, you.

Professional contact is making you feel uncomfortable? You can't quite put your finger on it, but it all seems a bit... off? Overly personal questions? Funny suggestions? Is it maybe just you, you're reading it all wrong?

I have heard this story too many times and I'm sick of it.

The answer is no.

Here is how these men work. It is not complicated. They knock you off guard, but just by a bit. Nothing that could be pegged down, nothing specifically identifiable. The goal is to confuse you, and, success, you're confused.

And when you're confused, you look for whatever social indicators are available to work out if this is/is not OK.

And, if you're like 98% of all the ladies in all the world, the first social indicators you will check will be from him. Do not do this. Do not allow the terms to be set by this man.

If you read the email twice to see if you were just being silly, he wins.

If you re-read your email to him twice, to check if there's anything in it that could give the wrong impression, he wins.

If any part of your brainspace is populated with worrying about the situation and you can't stop it, he wins.

These men are not good men. Do not follow terms set by these men.

These men are better at this than you think. Do not use subtle social indicators, they can twist them better than you can. And then they're setting the terms again. That's the goal. However it's framed, the goal of these men is to get power. Power over what happens in your head. If you try to get rid of him subtly, it won't work. And he'll twist it and twist it and then he's deeper than he was before.

He's not playing by fair social rules. Those who don't play by fair rules always have the upper hand over those who do.

So, you must tell the man to stop.

And when you do, he will act baffled, and hurt, and this will make you feel terrible, which is what it's supposed to do. He's hoping it will make you feel bad enough that you back down - at which point, he gets to start again, but with deeper hooks this time.

In the nicest possible way,

and with all the grace you can muster,

tell him to fuck off.